On Nov. 16, a coalition of nine Democratic senators wrote to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig demanding that the commission either withdraw or suspend its November 5 interpretation that requires prediction‑market exchanges to eliminate state‑by‑state geographic restrictions within 30 days. The senators argue the rule clashes with existing court orders that have forced platforms to geofence certain states and tribal lands. The same week, Politico reported that the CFTC is probing the industry’s two largest prediction‑market operators, Kalshi and Polymarket, intensifying scrutiny of the sector.

Senators Challenge the Geoblock Interpretation

The letter, led by Sen. Adam Schiff (D‑CA) and signed by every Democratic senator from California, Michigan, Nevada, Washington, plus Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D‑MN), contends that the CFTC’s interpretation violates court‑mandated geoblocks in Michigan, Nevada, Washington and on the lands of two California tribes. The senators note that a federal court in California ordered Kalshi to geofence tribal land just hours before the CFTC issued its interpretation, raising concerns about possible coordination between the regulator and platforms embroiled in litigation. They request that the commission clarify that court‑ordered geoblocks, tribal‑state compacts, or voluntarily imposed restrictions do not breach the CFTC’s “impartial access” rule, preserve all related records from Jan. 1, 2025, and provide a written response by Nov. 23.

CFTC’s Parallel Investigations of Kalshi and Polymarket

According to Politico, the CFTC’s enforcement division is conducting separate investigations into Kalshi and Polymarket, both of which have faced regulatory pressure for months. The Kalshi probe focuses on whether the company properly notified the agency about dozens of new contracts, with the regulator having recently warned the firm of potential charges for a procedural error involving a handful of contracts that were never live. Kalshi’s head of federal government relations, John Bivona, described the warning as “the agency doing their job.” The Polymarket investigation is broader, partly stemming from a 2022 settlement that required the platform to cease serving U.S. users. A CFTC spokesperson, Zach Fulton, said the agency’s enforcement “knows no bounds” and will pursue misconduct wherever it occurs. Polymarket’s spokesperson affirmed the company’s cooperation with regulators and law‑enforcement agencies to protect market integrity.

Political Landscape and Upcoming Actions

The senators’ letter arrives amid a broader political push on prediction markets. Republican Representatives Adrian Smith (NE) and Blake Moore (UT) have introduced bills targeting the industry, while Sen. Ted Cruz (TX) is preparing legislation that would bar platforms from offering sports contracts without explicit state or tribal authorization. Senate Agriculture Committee Chairman Sen. Richard Blumenthal (CT) has also urged congressional action over perceived CFTC ties to Kalshi. The Senate Agriculture Committee scheduled a hearing for Nov. 17 to consider President Donald Trump’s two CFTC nominees—Republican Nathan Anonick and Democrat Matthew Rowland—who would join Selig on the five‑member commission if confirmed. Democrats are set to take control of Congress in January, potentially reshaping the regulatory outlook for prediction markets.

What to Watch Next

Key developments to monitor include the CFTC’s response to the senators’ request by Nov. 23, any formal action taken against Kalshi or Polymarket, and the outcome of the Senate Agriculture Committee hearing on the new CFTC nominees. Legislative proposals from both parties could further define the permissible scope of state and tribal geoblocks for prediction‑market platforms.

FAQ

What is the CFTC’s November 5 geoblock interpretation?

The interpretation requires prediction‑market exchanges to eliminate state‑by‑state geographic restrictions within 30 days or explain why they cannot, asserting that such limits violate the CFTC’s rule for impartial market access.

Why are senators demanding the interpretation be withdrawn?

Senators argue the rule conflicts with existing court orders that have forced platforms to geofence certain states and tribal lands, potentially putting the exchanges in contempt of those orders.

What are the main focuses of the CFTC’s investigations into Kalshi and Polymarket?

The Kalshi probe examines whether the firm properly notified the CFTC about new contracts, while the Polymarket investigation relates to a 2022 settlement that barred the platform from serving U.S. users.