Coinbase filed a formal response with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission on Nov. 18, asking the regulator to preserve crypto‑focused prediction‑market contracts within the statutory definition of a swap and to clarify that the proposed rule’s illustrative categories are not a closed set.

The letter, addressed to CFTC Secretary Christopher Kirkpatrick, was signed by Julia Hueckel, director of regulatory policy, and David Shafer, director and associate general counsel for institutional legal at Coinbase.

Coinbase contended that the Commodity Exchange Act already captures event contracts and that the agency should phrase the amendment as an affirmation of existing coverage rather than as a creation of new swap status.

The company warned that a rigid list of examples could generate “negative inferences” about legitimate crypto offerings, pointing to recent state‑level enforcement actions and conflicting federal court decisions that have left market participants uncertain about classification.

Coinbase noted that it runs Coinbase Derivatives, a CFTC‑registered exchange, and that its brokerage arm provides event contracts to U.S. customers nationwide.

CFTC’s proposed amendment and industry response

In an Oct. 19 notice published in the Federal Register, the CFTC proposed to explicitly add event contracts—covering outcomes in sports, politics, culture and weather—to the definition of a swap. Chairman Michael Selig voted in favor, and no commissioner recorded a dissenting vote.

A companion interim rule seeks to exclude casino‑style gambling products from swap treatment; Coinbase expressed support for that carve‑out in a separate comment letter.

During a recent Bits + Bips discussion, host Austin Campbell described the situation as a lingering ambiguity from the Dodd‑Frank Act, noting that “many sort of informal understandings and zero formal understanding” exist about what qualifies as a swap.

Coinbase characterized crypto‑related event contracts as “representative of the type of financial event contract where price discovery, hedging, and informational value are sought by many active investors,” emphasizing their functional role in the market.