Kalshi Ltd. asked Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Melissa Crane on Nov. 20 to reject any renewed emergency restraining order that New York Attorney General Letitia James might file, arguing the order would effectively shut down the prediction‑market exchange across the United States.

Court rulings send $36 billion suit back to state court

U.S. District Judge Vernon S. Broderick ruled on Nov. 19 that the federal court lacked subject‑matter jurisdiction over New York’s enforcement action and returned the $36 billion lawsuit to state court. The judge denied New York’s request for attorneys’ fees, noting Kalshi presented reasonable grounds for removal.

The lawsuit, filed on July 31, accuses Kalshi of operating an unlicensed gambling business, seeking financial penalties, restitution for consumers and forfeiture of alleged unlawful profits. New York’s complaint also highlights Kalshi’s alleged allowance of customers aged 18 to 20, below the state’s 21‑year minimum for mobile sports betting.

Earlier, on Oct. 24, 2025, the New York State Gaming Commission issued a cease‑and‑desist notice to Kalshi. The company later secured a temporary deferment of enforcement, which U.S. District Judge Analisa Torres denied on July 7, 2026. Kalshi’s emergency injunction bid was rejected on July 27, 2026, and the appeal remains pending.

Kalshi argues emergency order would trigger market disruption

Kalshi’s counsel at Milbank highlighted the company’s $178 billion annualized trading volume and $22 billion valuation, warning that an ex parte restraining order would force liquidation of outstanding positions and disrupt markets where its contracts are permitted.

Sports‑event contracts launched in January 2025 expanded Kalshi’s product set beyond its July 2021 commercial launch, which originally offered contracts tied to financial indices. The New York order, according to Kalshi, would cover “sports, culture, elections and other events” offered “within or from New York or to persons in New York,” a scope that could bar the exchange from serving any U.S. customer because the company’s headquarters are in New York.

Attorney Daniel Wallach, a sports‑and‑gaming lawyer, told COINMAG that Kalshi’s letter argued James had not shown an emergency warranting an ex parte temporary restraining order. Wallach said Milbank pointed to the several‑month lag between Kalshi’s July 2021 launch and New York’s enforcement actions as evidence that the state had ample time to seek relief without resorting to emergency relief.

The letter also invoked the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s emergency order of Aug. 11, 2025, which invoked Section 8a(9) of the Commodity Exchange Act and instructed Kalshi to maintain operations under federal market requirements. The CFTC described a sudden shutdown as a “major market disturbance” and an “existential threat” to market participants and its regulatory jurisdiction.

Kalshi cited the Third Circuit’s decision in KalshiEX v. Flaherty, which held that federal commodities law pre‑empted New Jersey gambling restrictions. New Jersey has since asked the Supreme Court to review that ruling, and Kalshi argues the same pre‑emption logic should apply to New York’s order.

Milbank’s filing asked for an immediate status conference and for the court to consider formal briefing on the conflict between state gambling law and the CFTC’s federal mandate before any restraining order is imposed.

Kalshi contacted the attorney general’s office on Thursday evening, according to Wallach, to discuss scheduling further proceedings. State representatives said they would respond the next day, but Kalshi submitted its letter before receiving a reply.

New York maintains that Kalshi’s federal registration does not exempt it from state licensing, taxation and consumer‑protection requirements. The attorney general’s office emphasized the alleged access by 18‑ to 20‑year‑old customers as a key concern.

Kalshi’s latest objection focuses on the undefined reference to “other events” in the restraining order, arguing it could unintentionally encompass contracts on financial markets, economic indicators and other subjects unrelated to sports wagering.