Arca CIO Jeff Dorman calls Vitalik’s ETH store‑of‑value argument misguided
Arca’s chief investment officer Jeff Dorman challenged Vitalik Buterin’s claim that ETH is a store of value, arguing most of its market cap is speculative.
Arca’s chief investment officer Jeff Dorman challenged Vitalik Buterin’s claim that ETH is a store of value, arguing most of its market cap is speculative.
During a Thursday livestream, Arca’s chief investment officer Jeff Dorman called Ethereum co‑founder Vitalik Buterin’s recent pitch that ETH functions as a store of value “really misguided.” The criticism, reported by Unchained, centers on Dorman’s view that most of ETH’s market valuation is speculative rather than derived from intrinsic network use.
In an X thread on Nov. 8, Buterin argued that ETH’s role as a store of value makes more sense than its function as a fee‑burning token under EIP‑1559, which burns the base fee of each transaction. He warned that optimizing for the burn could clash with decentralization and capture resistance, suggesting the token’s value should be anchored in broader monetary principles.
Dorman acknowledged the philosophical appeal of Buterin’s case but said it rests on “memetic social value,” a term he uses for the “cool factor” that drives token prices. He pointed out that ETH’s utility is largely confined to the Ethereum network, noting that “the only successful layer one” is Hyperliquid’s integrated blockchain, exchange, and stablecoin platform.
Citing DefiLlama, Dorman said Ethereum generated roughly $6 million in revenue over the past 30 days – about $10 million in a weak month – which he annualized to $120 million. Applying a 20‑times earnings multiple yields a valuation of a few billion dollars, far short of ETH’s $236 billion market cap (CoinGecko). He estimated that about 200 million wallets hold an average of 0.1 ETH for gas, representing roughly $40 billion of on‑chain value. Adding revenue and gas‑related holdings, Dorman accounted for $45‑$50 billion of the total, leaving roughly $200 billion as speculative “social value or hopium.”
Dorman suggested that if Ethereum truly depends on applications like Uniswap and issuers such as Circle, the network could consider taxing these services to test their willingness to stay. He did not propose a specific rate, but said it would need to be “pretty high” to gauge the resilience of the ecosystem.
Analysts will monitor whether Ethereum’s developers respond to Dorman’s critique with changes to fee structures or incentive mechanisms. Additionally, market participants will watch for any shift in the narrative around ETH’s store‑of‑value status, especially as competing layer‑1s continue to attract developers seeking lower costs.
He uses the term to describe the portion of ETH’s market cap that he believes is driven by speculative sentiment rather than actual network usage.
Dorman cited DefiLlama data showing about $6 million in revenue over the past 30 days, roughly $10 million in a weak month.
He proposes taxing major applications and issuers to see whether they would remain on Ethereum or migrate to cheaper blockchains.
Discussion 0