GameStop chief executive Ryan Cohen said the move toward download‑only releases harms both consumers and the retailer, a point he raised as Grand Theft Auto 6 prepares to debut Thursday without a physical disc. The title, developed by Take‑Two Interactive, will be sold as an $80 digital download, with retailers offering boxed codes rather than traditional cartridges.

Pre‑owned revenue drops sharply

Cohen highlighted that pre‑owned and refurbished games, which account for 22% of GameStop’s total sales, generated roughly $171 million in the quarter that ended August 1, a decline of 32% compared with the same period a year earlier, according to Bloomberg data. He said the decline reflects the growing difficulty of reselling games when publishers eliminate physical copies.

The CEO argued that publishers benefit from the digital model because used copies compete with new sales, adding that “they’re taking away competition.” He declined to name specific publishers but noted that Take‑Two’s decision to launch GTA 6 as a download‑only product exemplifies the trend.

Legislative response to digital ownership

Cohen disclosed a recent meeting with New York Representative Ritchie Torres, a Democrat who is sponsoring the Power to the Players Act. The bill would require gaming companies to guarantee that buyers retain ongoing access to the titles they purchase, countering the notion that a digital purchase can be revoked at any time.

Torres told Bloomberg in October that a game that can be removed “the moment a company pulls the plug is not a purchase. It is a rental disguised as a sale.” The legislation aims to protect consumers from losing access to games they have paid for, an issue that has gained attention after several high‑profile digital‑only launches.

Industry moves and broader context

The shift toward digital distribution is not limited to Take‑Two. Sony announced in July that it will cease production of physical discs for new PlayStation games starting January 2028, a decision analysts say will disproportionately affect low‑income gamers who rely on used discs. PlayStation founder Ken Kutaragi dismissed the backlash as a “mentality issue,” while a veteran from Infinity Ward noted that publishers have been pushing to eliminate discs since 2007.

In Europe, the Stop Killing Games campaign has gathered 1.3 million signatures for a European Citizens’ Initiative that calls for publishers to keep games playable after official support ends. Courts are also hearing cases on digital ownership; Sony has argued that digital games cannot be owned, prompting some in the crypto community to propose blockchain‑based solutions as an alternative.