Cardano community votes down Toto Finance's 22M ADA copper reserve proposal
Cardano delegated representatives rejected a 22 million ADA request to purchase physical copper, preserving the network’s remaining treasury capacity.
Cardano delegated representatives rejected a 22 million ADA request to purchase physical copper, preserving the network’s remaining treasury capacity.
Cardano’s on‑chain governance system turned down Toto Finance’s bid to allocate 22 million ADA from the network treasury for a strategic reserve of physical copper. The vote, which closed on November 15, saw overwhelming opposition, with DRep‑weighted support falling far short of the 67% threshold required for treasury withdrawals.
Update, Nov 16, 15:51 UTC: According to The Crypto Basic, the vote involved 126 DReps against, five in favor and eight abstaining, and the proposal expired at 21:44 UTC on November 15 with no treasury funds released. The Constitutional Committee split was three members voting no and four abstaining, clarifying the earlier report that only seven members voted against or abstained.
According to crypto.news, only 0.51% of counted DRep voting power backed the proposal, while the Constitutional Committee gave it no approval. Seven committee members either voted against the request’s constitutionality or abstained, and the overall DRep tally was more than 140‑to‑1 against the plan. Cardanoscan’s record shows roughly 20.02 million ADA in favor versus 2.86 billion ADA voting no, with an additional 131.29 million ADA assigned to a no‑confidence stance.
Toto Finance intended to spend 14.72 million ADA (about 66.9% of the request) on COMEX Grade 1 copper cathodes, storing the metal in a U.S. warehouse. The remaining ADA would cover technology, operations, execution, and independent oversight. Critics highlighted several risks: high fees, incomplete custody protections, and the possibility of losing public funds in a commodity venture. The plan also called for issuing a CuTT token on Ethereum, then bridging it to Cardano, which DReps questioned as an unnecessary cross‑chain step.
The rejected withdrawal would have consumed more than half of the 42.6 million ADA still available under Cardano’s 500 million ADA spending cap, which runs until roughly July 2027. To date, 457.4 million ADA has been withdrawn, leaving the remaining capacity for future proposals. At the November 16 market price of about $0.15 per ADA, the 22 million ADA request equated to roughly $3.3 million, lower than the $5 million valuation cited when the proposal was first announced.
Observers will monitor whether Toto Finance revises its proposal to address the governance concerns, particularly around custody and fee structures. The Cardano community’s strict stance may also influence future treasury requests, especially those involving off‑chain assets or cross‑chain token issuance.
Toto Finance aimed to create a strategic reserve of physical copper, purchase the metal, and issue a CuTT token representing each pound of copper.
It failed to meet the 67% DRep support threshold and received no approval from the Constitutional Committee, with concerns over fees, custody, and the use of public treasury funds for a private commodity venture.
Approximately 42.6 million ADA remains available under Cardano’s 500 million ADA spending limit, which is expected to run until July 2027.
Discussion 0